Sponsor Advertisement
Schumer Lags Behind AOC in Jewish Democrat Support, Poll Shows

Schumer Lags Behind AOC in Jewish Democrat Support, Poll Shows

A new poll reveals that Senator Chuck Schumer is trailing behind Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez among Jewish Democrats in a hypothetical Senate primary.

New York Senator Chuck Schumer may encounter challenges in his upcoming re-election bid, as a recent poll indicates that he is behind Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez among Jewish Democrats. The poll, conducted by Honan Strategy Group (HSG) for the Jewish Voters Action Network (JVAC) between May 15 and 18, shows Ocasio-Cortez leading with 45% to Schumer's 33%, with 17% of respondents undecided.

Schumer, 74, has historically relied on the Jewish electorate as a key part of his support base. However, the early numbers from this poll suggest a potential shift in voter sentiment. Maury Litwack, co-founder of JVAC, described the findings as "a massive wake-up call for Schumer," highlighting a loss of support not only in the broader Democratic Party but particularly within the Jewish community.

The decline in Schumer's support is attributed more to his perceived shortcomings than to a surge in enthusiasm for Ocasio-Cortez, according to Litwack's comments to the New York Post. Criticisms of Schumer's performance include his silence during a period of rising antisemitic protests and his failure to pass the Antisemitism Awareness Act, despite the Democrats controlling both the Senate and the White House last year.

Furthermore, Schumer was implicated in an advisory role to Columbia University regarding the handling of reports of antisemitism on campus, as per a House investigative report. Schumer has refuted these allegations, but they have nonetheless impacted his standing among Jewish voters.

Adding to Schumer's troubles, earlier this year he faced backlash from within his party for supporting a government funding bill instead of pushing for a shutdown in protest of then-President Donald Trump's policies. Ocasio-Cortez notably criticized Schumer and Senate Democrats for this decision, calling it "a huge slap in the face" to the party's loyalists and to lawmakers opposing Trump.

A separate poll by Data for Progress paralleled these findings, placing Ocasio-Cortez 19 points ahead of Schumer in a similar 2028 primary scenario. Moreover, this poll positioned Schumer as the most unpopular Democrat tested, with Ocasio-Cortez ranking favorably behind Bernie Sanders, Kamala Harris, and Elizabeth Warren.

When confronted with a question regarding his poor approval ratings by CNN Capitol Correspondent Raju on April 30, Schumer downplayed the significance of polls, emphasizing party unity and ongoing efforts against Trump. "Polls come and go. Our party is united. We're on our front foot, we're stepping forward, going after Trump and having real success," Schumer stated.

With the election cycle for 2028 still in its early stages, these poll results may not fully capture the electorate's eventual decision-making. Nonetheless, they serve as an indicator of current voter attitudes and may influence strategies as candidates prepare for the primaries.

Advertisement

The Flipside: Different Perspectives

Progressive View

The recent poll results suggest a progressive tide within the Democratic Party, as evidenced by Ocasio-Cortez's lead over Schumer among Jewish Democrats. Progressives might interpret this as an indication of the party base's desire for bold leadership and a clear stance against what they view as regressive policies, particularly in the context of Trump-era politics. Ocasio-Cortez's vocal criticism of Israeli policies and her outspoken nature on social issues resonate with voters seeking assertive representation.

Furthermore, progressives could argue that Schumer's perceived inaction during critical moments, such as the rise in antisemitic protests, and the failure to push through key legislation, reveal a disconnect with the urgency of addressing social justice and human rights concerns. The willingness to compromise and maintain the status quo may be increasingly seen as insufficient in addressing the needs of a diverse and evolving electorate.

Conservative View

The polling data indicating Senator Schumer's lag behind Representative Ocasio-Cortez among Jewish Democrats signifies a potential recalibration of political allegiances within the party. Conservatives might argue that Schumer's centrist approach, often aimed at bipartisanship and stability, is losing favor among a base that is shifting towards more progressive stances. This could be perceived as a reflection of the Democratic Party's internal struggle to define its identity, with a growing faction advocating for more radical change versus established practices.

Additionally, Schumer's failure to pass the Antisemitism Awareness Act and his alleged advice to Columbia University could be seen as a failure to protect Jewish interests, which traditionally align with conservative values of community and religious freedom. The senator's decision to support a government funding bill, potentially averting a government shutdown, may also be critiqued by conservatives as a missed opportunity to take a firmer stand against opposition policies.

Common Ground

Both conservatives and progressives can agree that the Jewish Democratic electorate's shift in support raises important questions about representation, community interests, and political accountability. There is consensus on the need for leaders to take decisive action against antisemitism and to uphold the values of their constituents. Moreover, both sides may acknowledge the significance of engaging with and addressing the concerns of all voter demographics to maintain a robust and responsive political system.