The transition team for New York City Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani faced a significant setback this week when Catherine Almonte Da Costa, poised to become Mamdani's director of appointments, tendered her resignation. The abrupt departure came in the wake of a public outcry over a series of antisemitic social media posts Da Costa made between 2011 and 2012, which only recently resurfaced.
The controversial posts, which included derogatory references to Jewish people, were identified on a now-deleted account associated with Da Costa. The Anti-Defamation League of New York and New Jersey was swift to condemn the posts, labeling them as echoing "classic antisemitic tropes" and calling for accountability from both Da Costa and Mayor-elect Mamdani. "Tweeting about 'money hungry Jews' is indefensible," the ADL stated. "Her posts require immediate explanation not just from Ms. Da Costa, but also from the mayor-elect."
In response to the backlash, Da Costa took down her social media account and issued a public apology. Speaking to The Judge Street Journal, which initially reported the incident, she expressed "deep regret for my past statements," asserting they do not reflect her current beliefs. With the controversy growing, Da Costa, who is the mother of Jewish children, stated her resignation was prompted by a desire to not distract from the incoming administration's work.
Mamdani accepted Da Costa's resignation in a succinct statement, acknowledging her remorse and decision to step aside. This incident is not the first to challenge Mamdani's transition. Earlier in the week, Mamdani faced criticism for appointing Mysonne Linen, a convicted armed robber, to his transition team, a move he defended as aligned with his belief in second chances. This appointment, too, received considerable pushback, particularly in light of Mamdani's pending inauguration in January.
Da Costa's resignation comes amid additional scrutiny for past comments about law enforcement, which have also sparked controversy. This is not her first role in city government, having previously worked in former Mayor Bill de Blasio's administration. The contrast between her past remarks and the values of diversity and inclusion Mamdani has committed to is stark, adding to the challenges he faces.
The unfolding events have intensified scrutiny on Mamdani's judgment and the direction of his administration, especially amidst his struggles with the city's Jewish community. Despite rejecting hate speech in general, Mamdani's reluctance to specifically condemn the "Globalize the Intifada" slogan used at pro-Palestinian protests has been a point of contention with Jewish leaders.
Da Costa's resignation marks a tumultuous phase for Mamdani's transition, raising questions about his leadership as he prepares to assume office. As the city looks ahead to this new chapter, the selection and vetting processes for key appointees are under the microscope, highlighting the importance of thorough scrutiny of public figures' backgrounds.
