Sponsor Advertisement
Issaquah High School Teacher Reinstated After Controversial Leave

Issaquah High School Teacher Reinstated After Controversial Leave

An Issaquah High School teacher has returned to teaching after a leave due to a TikTok video with provocative lyrics about ICE and President Trump.

Kelsey Early, a Spanish teacher at Issaquah High School in Washington state, has resumed her teaching duties following a brief administrative leave. Early was placed on leave after a TikTok video emerged showing her singing a version of the National Anthem with altered lyrics that included profanities directed at Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and President Donald Trump. The video, which also expressed support for Palestine, sparked controversy within the school community and beyond.

The Issaquah School District confirmed that Early returned to her classroom on October 17, 2025, concluding the investigation into the incident. The district emphasized its commitment to a safe, supportive learning environment, focusing on purposeful and productive instruction for all students. During the investigative process, Early's leave was described as non-disciplinary, with the district citing the importance of balancing staff expression with the orderly operation of schools.

The video in question contained the lyrics "F*ck ICE and F*ck Trump, Free Palestine," sung to the melody of the National Anthem, and indicated Early's intent to modify the Pledge of Allegiance in her classroom. This incident occurred against a backdrop of ongoing debates within the Issaquah School District regarding anti-Israel sentiment, heightened by the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023, and subsequent student walkouts.

Parents and community members have expressed dissatisfaction with the district's decision to reinstate Early. The district has faced challenges managing the expression of various viewpoints within its schools, particularly given Issaquah's significant Israeli and Jewish population.

In response to the controversy, the district provided an exclusive statement to The Ari Hoffman Show on Talk Radio 570 KVI, asserting that the teacher's First Amendment rights and cooperation were considered during the investigation. Additionally, the district plans to remind staff of the regulations and laws governing expression in educational settings.

As the situation developed, social media became a platform for diverse reactions. Some tweets criticized Early's actions as promoting terrorism and threatening the community, while others organized walkouts to commemorate the Hamas-led massacre as a "great achievement."

Issaquah High School principal Erin Connolly informed parents of the planned walkouts, stating that students participating would receive unexcused absences and reiterating the school's stance against harassment, bullying, or vandalism related to protest activities. The school also had to address the removal of protest posters that were illegally glued to school property.

Advertisement

The Flipside: Different Perspectives

Progressive View

The reinstatement of Kelsey Early to Issaquah High School following her politically charged TikTok video presents a complex issue from a progressive standpoint. Advocates for social justice and equity recognize the importance of allowing teachers the freedom to express their views, particularly when they touch on pressing societal issues such as immigration policy and international conflict. However, the manner and context in which these views are expressed are crucial to maintaining a constructive educational environment.

Educators have a unique platform to influence and empower the next generation. It is imperative that this platform be used responsibly to encourage critical thinking and inclusivity, rather than to propagate personal political agendas. While Early's right to free speech should be respected, it is equally important to consider the impact of her actions on the students' right to an unbiased education and the well-being of the school community, especially in areas with significant cultural diversity.

Moreover, the situation calls for a broader conversation about how educational systems can address systemic issues and support teachers in engaging with sensitive topics in a manner that promotes understanding and equity. The school district's response to the incident, focusing on creating a supportive learning environment, aligns with these goals. However, it is crucial that such responses also consider the wider implications of the actions taken and the messages they send to both educators and students about accountability and respect.

Conservative View

The recent reinstatement of Kelsey Early, a teacher at Issaquah High School, has raised important questions about the boundaries of free speech and professionalism within our educational institutions. From a conservative perspective, the upholding of traditional values and respect for national symbols is paramount. The incident involving Early, who utilized her platform as an educator to disseminate a message that many perceive as disrespectful to the President and the rule of law, exemplifies the tension between individual liberty and the responsibility that comes with the freedom of expression.

The case also highlights the need for a clear and consistent application of rules governing conduct within schools. It is essential to protect the right to free speech while ensuring that this right is not exercised in a manner that disrupts the educational process or infringes upon the rights of others. The teacher's actions, which included the intent to alter the Pledge of Allegiance, can be seen as an overreach that infringes upon the students' right to a politically neutral education.

Moreover, the response to the teacher's conduct reflects the importance of community standards and the expectation of educators to serve as role models. The role of a teacher extends beyond the delivery of curriculum; it includes fostering an environment conducive to learning and upholding values that society deems important. As such, the reinstatement of Early may be seen as a missed opportunity to affirm these principles.

Common Ground

In the case of Kelsey Early's reinstatement at Issaquah High School, there is room for agreement across the spectrum of political beliefs. Both conservative and progressive viewpoints value the principle of free speech, recognizing its fundamental role in a democratic society. Additionally, there is a shared understanding of the importance of a safe and productive learning environment for students, where education is not hindered by external controversies.

Agreement can also be found in the recognition that educators hold a position of trust and influence, carrying the responsibility to impart knowledge and values to students. There is a common interest in ensuring that teachers are able to discuss relevant and contemporary issues with students, while also maintaining a level of professionalism and neutrality that respects the diverse backgrounds and beliefs of the school community.

Ultimately, both perspectives can concur on the need for clear guidelines and professional development for educators on how to navigate political expression within the classroom. This approach would support teachers in facilitating respectful and informed discussions, thus enhancing the educational experience for all students.