In a recent internal assessment, FBI Director Kash Patel is being criticized by a group consisting of active-duty and retired agents and analysts for his performance during the first six months of his tenure. The report and various sources within the bureau have expressed concerns over the leadership, indicating challenges and discontent within the ranks.
The criticism emerged shortly after the White House dismissed rumors that President Donald Trump intended to remove Patel from his position. The 115-page report paints Patel as "in over his head" and depicts his deputy, Dan Bongino, as "something of a clown." These opinions were shared by individuals from an alliance that has previously raised alarms regarding Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) policies and politicization during President Biden's administration.
Internal descriptions of the bureau under Patel's leadership liken it to a "rudderless ship" and "all f–ked up," suggesting a lack of direction and internal cohesion. Some of the discontent is based on Patel's handling of the assassination of Charlie Kirk in Salt Lake City, including allegedly premature public remarks and taking undue credit for work done by other agencies.
Sources within the bureau have questioned Patel's experience and demeanor for the role of FBI director. Despite some characterizing him as "very personable and likable," there is a sentiment that he has fostered a culture of mistrust and uncertainty. The report also highlights an incident on September 11, 2025, when Patel insisted on wearing an FBI raid jacket before appearing at the site of Kirk's assassination, which diverted resources and attention from the investigation.
The bureau's internal strife is further illustrated by Patel's reaction to discussions about his request for an FBI firearm, leading to ordered polygraph tests to identify critics. This punitive measure has been met with disapproval from respected figures within the organization.
The report notes an ongoing resistance to Patel from within the FBI, some of which may stem from opposition to President Trump. This is reflected in the political leanings apparent in the agency, with televisions in FBI field offices reportedly tuned to MSNBC and CNN, as opposed to Fox News.
The report, structured like an official FBI intelligence assessment, is based on insights from 24 FBI sources and sub-sources, using specific incidents to underscore broader leadership concerns. The combination of internal criticism and public scrutiny presents a challenge for the FBI leadership, as the organization grapples with perceptions of inexperience and unprofessional conduct at the top.
