In a decision that has sparked community debate, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit ruled on Friday to move a "family-friendly" drag queen performance, initially planned for the Naples Pridefest at Cambier Park, indoors. The ruling came just before the weekend event, with the court siding with the city of Naples to prioritize public decency and protect minors from exposure to the show, which was to be located next to a well-visited children's playground.
The annual Naples Pridefest, a celebration of diversity and inclusion, scheduled the drag show as part of its outdoor activities. However, the court's recent decision has halted the outdoor performance, directing it to be held under the same two permit conditions that applied in the previous years of 2023 and 2024, when it was successfully staged indoors. The appeals court's ruling supports the city's authority to regulate events in the interest of child welfare, reversing a preliminary injunction from a judge who had initially been sympathetic to the event organizers' complaints.
In April, the Naples City Council had voted 5-2 in favor of moving the drag show indoors and limiting attendance to adults only, a decision reflecting public apprehension over exposing children to adult-themed performances. The council's decision was subsequently challenged in court by Naples Pride and the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), who were granted a preliminary injunction against the restrictions.
With the appeals court ruling, the contentious debate over the appropriateness of certain public events near children has found temporary resolution. Pastor Jeff Donaldson of Christ Community Church expressed his contentment with the outcome, citing it as a win for both families and public decency. Similarly, Liberty Counsel, a nonprofit organization advocating for religious freedom and traditional values, celebrated the court's decision as a "win for decency."
Florida Representative Byron Donalds, currently a candidate for the state's gubernatorial race, also welcomed the decision. His wife, Erika Donalds, took to social media to recognize the efforts of the city and advocacy groups in protecting children's welfare, celebrating it as a victory for Naples families.
Following the court's decision, the drag show was moved to the Norris Center, an indoor venue with a capacity of 200 guests per show. Three performances were scheduled, with the organizers accepting donations and seating offered on a first-come, first-served basis. The larger outdoor festival continued as planned, with Naples Pride and the ACLU of Florida inviting the community to engage in the festivities.
The case underscores the ongoing cultural conflicts that communities face regarding public decency, children’s exposure to adult content, and the balance between freedom of expression and community standards.
