Sponsor Advertisement
Concerns Rise as Students Struggle to Focus on Full-Length Films

Concerns Rise as Students Struggle to Focus on Full-Length Films

Film professors report a growing inability among students to watch entire movies without distraction, reflecting a concerning trend in attention spans.

In educational institutions across the United States, film professors are facing a perplexing challenge: students enrolled in cinema courses are increasingly unable to sit through entire feature-length films without resorting to their phones. This phenomenon was recently highlighted in a comprehensive report by The Atlantic, which gathered insights from twenty film studies professors nationwide.

Craig Erpelding from the University of Wisconsin at Madison expressed his dismay, noting that what once seemed like enjoyable homework has become a task students are reluctant to do. This shift has been particularly pronounced in the last decade, with the post-pandemic era exacerbating the issue. Students are demonstrating significant difficulty in maintaining focus for the duration of full-length films, a critical component of their coursework.

Malcolm Turvey, who leads the Film and Media Studies Program at Tufts University, attempted to counteract this problem by implementing an electronics ban during screenings. Despite this, he observed that approximately half of his students still sneak glances at their mobile devices. Similarly, Akira Mizuta Lippit of the University of Southern California's film program likened his students' behavior to that of nicotine addicts, unable to resist the pull of their phones during movie screenings.

The problem extends to crucial moments of cinematic artistry. Lippit recounted how, despite being instructed to pay attention to the essential final scene of Francis Ford Coppola’s "The Conversation," several students were still distracted by their phones. This indicates a deeper issue with attention that is not limited to the classroom but reflects broader changes in media consumption habits.

Interestingly, this trend is not only affecting educational settings. Matt Damon, during an appearance on "The Joe Rogan Experience," revealed that Netflix advises filmmakers to adapt their content to these changing viewer habits by including early action sequences and repeated plot details to cater to multitasking audiences.

In response to these attention challenges, some professors, like Kyle Stine from Johns Hopkins, are pioneering courses in slow cinema, featuring minimalist films with minimal narrative to encourage extended focus. Rick Warner of the University of North Carolina assigns slow-paced films to strain students' viewing habits and help them retrain their perception and concentration.

This issue parallels a similar concern in literary education. Nicholas Dames of Columbia University has noticed incoming students struggling with complete book readings, a task once deemed routine. This suggests a broader cultural shift in how the digital age is reshaping the capacity for sustained attention in young adults.

Advertisement

The Flipside: Different Perspectives

Progressive View

The attention span crisis among students is indicative of systemic issues within our educational and societal structures. Progressive analysis would suggest that this trend is not merely a failure of individual willpower but a consequence of living in a technology-saturated environment that has reshaped cognitive processes. Students are products of an era where information is fragmented, and constant engagement with digital media has become the norm.

From a progressive stance, addressing this challenge requires a multifaceted approach that acknowledges the complexity of the problem. Educational institutions must adapt by creating curricula that recognize the changing nature of attention and learning. Progressive strategies might include incorporating technology in a way that enhances focus rather than detracts from it, as well as teaching methods that actively engage students in the material.

Moreover, the issue of dwindling attention spans is tied to broader concerns of equity and access. Not all students have the same background or support systems to navigate the demands of higher education. Ensuring that all students, regardless of socio-economic status, have the tools and support to develop strong concentration skills is crucial. Progressive policies would advocate for a stronger investment in mental health resources and learning accommodations to help students manage and overcome these new challenges.

Conservative View

The recent revelations about students’ inability to watch full-length films without distraction is a troubling symptom of a larger societal shift. From a conservative perspective, this issue is tied to the rapid technological advancements that have stymied the development of individual discipline and self-control. The traditional values of patience and perseverance are critical for educational success and personal growth. By succumbing to constant digital stimulation, students are not only undermining their academic responsibilities but also their capacity to engage deeply with content that requires sustained attention.

Educators, such as Professor Kyle Stine and Rick Warner, who encourage students to confront their shortened attention spans by exposing them to slow-paced films, are attempting to restore a sense of personal responsibility. This approach aligns with conservative principles by challenging students to reclaim their autonomy over their distractions rather than allowing technology to dictate their focus. The ability to concentrate and fully engage with complex ideas is foundational for a market-driven economy that values depth of knowledge and critical thinking.

Furthermore, the conservative viewpoint would advocate for a cultural reinforcement of traditional educational standards, which emphasize the completion of assigned tasks as a matter of personal honor and commitment. By instilling these values, educators can help counteract the prevailing trends that threaten to diminish the intellectual rigor necessary for maintaining a competitive and innovative society.

Common Ground

Despite differing perspectives, there is common ground in recognizing that the current attention span crisis among students has profound implications for their academic performance and future success. Both conservative and progressive viewpoints can agree on the importance of adapting educational practices to better serve students in this changing landscape.

A bipartisan approach might include support for innovative teaching methods that both challenge and accommodate students' shifting attention spans. There could be a collective effort to promote media literacy, teaching students how to engage with digital content in a mindful and deliberate manner, which is a shared goal across the political spectrum.

Additionally, both sides can concur on the value of equipping students with the skills necessary to navigate a complex and fast-paced world. This includes fostering environments that encourage deep focus and concentration, whether through slow cinema courses or by integrating technology in education in a constructive way.