Sponsor Advertisement
Social Media and the New Military: Navigating Ethics and Influence

Social Media and the New Military: Navigating Ethics and Influence

Military influencers on social media spark debate, balancing educational content with personal branding, while testing the boundaries of Pentagon ethics rules.

The U.S. armed forces, long regarded as bastions of discipline and unity, are currently experiencing a cultural shift as some service members, known as military influencers, leverage social media to build personal brands. Captain Austin Von Letkemann, a notable figure among these influencers, has recently garnered nearly 120 million Instagram views, underscoring the significant reach and impact such individuals can have.

Captain Von Letkemann, along with his peers, has been part of the "Creative Reserve" program, an initiative by the Army aimed at utilizing the popularity of military influencers for publicity and recruitment purposes. This program, however, is currently on hold as it has stirred both interest and controversy. The Daily Mail reported that the program has produced advertising value worth millions of dollars, a testament to the potent influence wielded by these service members.

The content produced by military influencers varies widely, from informative pieces about military life and career advice to more personal and sometimes controversial posts. Army Psyop Hayley Lujan and Air Force medic Rylee Roast, both with substantial online followings, have been known to post images that blend their military identity with more provocative elements, leading to discussions about the appropriateness of such content.

Former Marine Dominic Wakeham and others have been criticized for posts that some argue may cross ethical or professional lines. In contrast, influencers like Johnny Vargas advocate for the positive aspects of their efforts, highlighting how they educate and inform service members, veterans, and their families about benefits and resources while addressing issues like gender bias in the military.

These influencers have also found financial success through their online presence, with some earning figures upward of $500,000 annually through consulting and brand deals. This income far exceeds that of many senior enlisted soldiers and raises questions about the legality of profiting from one's military status.

The Department of Defense has regulations in place that prohibit service members from using their military role for personal gain, but the interpretation of these rules in the context of social media remains a gray area. While some critics argue that such activities undermine military discipline, others believe these influencers serve an essential role in connecting with broader audiences and boosting morale.

The ethical debate intensifies as the military grapples with reconciling its traditional values with the burgeoning influence of content creators on social media. Captain Von Letkemann states his goal is to spread positivity: "I want to make people happy, make them laugh, and when I leave the military, build a brand and business as big as possible."

As the conversation continues, the military community is forced to examine the evolving landscape where discipline meets the digital age, and where the lines between education, connection, and personal branding are increasingly blurred.

Advertisement

The Flipside: Different Perspectives

Progressive View

From a progressive standpoint, the rise of military influencers on social media raises important questions about equity, representation, and the role of institutions in adapting to societal changes. The ability of these individuals to communicate directly with the public and provide insights into military life is a positive step toward transparency and breaking down barriers between the military and civilian spheres.

Social justice considerations come into play when examining the content of certain influencers who challenge gender norms and stereotypes within the military. Advocates like Johnny Vargas highlight the systemic issues that women face in the armed forces, using their platforms to promote understanding and advocate for equality.

Moreover, progressives would argue for the potential collective benefits of these influencers' activities, such as broadening recruitment efforts and educating the public about military careers. Yet, these benefits must be weighed against the need for ethical standards that ensure content creators do not exploit their status or detract from the mission of the military.

In addressing these concerns, a progressive approach would involve establishing a clear framework that allows for the expression and empowerment of individual service members while safeguarding the collective well-being and ethical standards of the military community.

Conservative View

The emergence of military influencers on social media presents an intriguing case for the conservative perspective. At its core, conservatism values the principles of individual liberty, including the freedom for service members to engage with the public and create content that may benefit their post-service careers. However, this must be balanced against the tenet of limited government, which in this context means adherence to the established ethics and codes of conduct designed to preserve the integrity of the military institution.

Financial independence is another cornerstone of conservative values, and the ability of these influencers to monetize their platforms through consulting and brand deals aligns with the free-market principle of entrepreneurship. Nevertheless, it is crucial that such endeavors do not compromise the traditional values of discipline and respect for the chain of command, which are fundamental to military effectiveness.

The conservative argument would thus advocate for a clear demarcation of ethical guidelines that allows service members to engage in social media activities without undermining military discipline or using their status for unfair advantage. Encouraging personal responsibility, these influencers should also serve as role models, demonstrating how one can navigate the intersection of military service and personal branding with integrity and respect for military traditions.

Common Ground

Despite differing viewpoints, there is room for consensus on the topic of military influencers. Both conservative and progressive sides can agree on the importance of maintaining the integrity and discipline of the military while recognizing the potential benefits of service members engaging with the public on social media.

Shared values include the respect for military tradition, the need for ethical guidelines, and the acknowledgment that social media can be a powerful tool for education, recruitment, and connecting with the community. There is also mutual recognition that service members should be allowed to prepare for their post-military careers, provided it does not interfere with their duties or compromise ethical standards.

Finding common ground involves crafting policies that balance individual expression with the collective mission of the military, ensuring that service members can be both effective influencers and disciplined defenders of the nation.