In Montana, a voicemail left by Helena City Commission candidate Haley McKnight directed at Senator Tim Sheehy (R-MT) has stirred a statewide controversy. The incident occurred on July 1, following Sheehy's vote in favor of the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act," backed by President Donald Trump. The contentious voicemail, which lasted approximately one minute, featured McKnight expressing violent and vulgar sentiments, wishing the senator to suffer from pancreatic cancer, die in the street, and become infertile.
"We hope Ms. McKnight gets the help she clearly needs and wish her well." - Statement from Senator Tim Sheehy's office.
While conservatives have expressed outrage over the language used, law enforcement agencies have confirmed that the incident has been officially reported. McKnight, who also runs a local business and presides over the Helena Young Professionals group, defended her actions. She described the voicemail as an expression of "justifiable rage" in response to policies she believes are detrimental to Montanans. National Review quoted McKnight accusing Senator Sheehy of prioritizing personal and financial interests over the needs of his constituents. She clarified that her frustration was driven by the desire to defend vulnerable communities rather than personal animosity toward Sheehy.
This event has brought to light a pattern of aggressive rhetoric aimed at conservative figures. A previous report by Resist the Mainstream documented a similar case involving Democratic nominee Jay Jones, who sent death wishes via text to then-Republican House Speaker Todd Gilbert in 2022. Such cases are indicative of a worrisome trend where the political climate and the safety of Republican officials are increasingly threatened.
Media portrayal of these incidents has become a subject of criticism among conservative circles. Some commentators argue that the press tends to downplay aggressive political threats, framing them as mere expressions of frustration rather than taking them seriously. The Western Journal highlighted that news outlets, including KTVH and MTN, reported McKnight's justifications, which, according to critics, could inadvertently diminish the gravity of the threats.
McKnight's involvement in politics extends to active participation in progressive causes since her move to Montana in 2017. Her campaign platform shows a commitment to sustainability, public transportation, and the regulation of short-term rentals. Conversely, Senator Sheehy's office has decided against legal action, instead issuing a statement through spokesman Tate Mitchell, wishing McKnight well and confirming that law enforcement has been notified of the voicemail.
Analysts warn that episodes like McKnight's voicemail highlight an escalation in partisan rhetoric. They emphasize the need for campaigns and government bodies to uphold norms of accountability, stating that threatening communications should not only disqualify candidates from holding office but also necessitate legal and institutional responses.
As the city commission elections approach, the people of Montana face a pivotal discussion on the balance between free speech rights and the onus on public figures to engage in civil discourse.
