Sponsor Advertisement
Tragic End to Romney Marriage Preceded by Divorce Filings

Tragic End to Romney Marriage Preceded by Divorce Filings

George Scott Romney filed for divorce from Carrie Elizabeth Romney four months before her death from a parking garage fall, with financial disputes indicated.

In a development that has garnered public attention, George Scott Romney, the elder brother of politician Mitt Romney, filed for divorce from his wife, Carrie Elizabeth Romney, mere months before her untimely death in a fall from a California parking structure. The 81-year-old, who once aspired to public office, cited irreconcilable differences in the June court filings, which have been made publicly available by media outlets.

The divorce papers reveal George Scott Romney's intent to "terminate the court's ability to award support" to either party, an indication of a desire to prevent court intervention in the financial aspects of their separation. Subsequent documents pointed to an agreement between the parties to "mediate property and support," suggesting an inclination towards private negotiation over court-ordered settlements.

Carrie Romney, 64, responded to the divorce proceedings with legal counteractions, requesting alimony and legal expenses coverage. She also sought to revert to her previous surname, Dimas. The case was still active when Carrie Romney's body was found at the base of a parking garage in Valencia, approximately 35 miles north of downtown Los Angeles, on a Friday night. The discovery sent ripples of shock through the community where the couple resided.

Law enforcement officials, who do not suspect foul play, are investigating whether the incident was a suicide or an accident. The Los Angeles County medical examiner has deferred the cause of death, pending further analysis. The couple's marriage, which began in 2012, was headed for conclusion when they separated in May, with the divorce petition following in June.

Despite claims of no shared property, records and evidence suggest the couple cohabited in a Valencia condominium valued at $725,000, which has become a key point in understanding their pre-separation living arrangements. Neighbors, who spoke to reporters, remembered Carrie as a pleasant community member. George Scott Romney was seen in the neighborhood shortly after the incident, amidst a backdrop of unusually dreary Southern California weather.

Carrie Romney's financial situation during the divorce remains uncertain, though the legal filings hint at disputes over money and support. Her financial history includes a 2001 Chapter 7 bankruptcy filing with a previous husband. The divorce from George Scott Romney would have been her third.

Advertisement

The Flipside: Different Perspectives

Progressive View

The tragic case of Carrie Elizabeth Romney's death following her husband's divorce filing raises questions about the equity and support structures available to individuals navigating the end of a marriage. Progressives often view divorce as not only the dissolution of a personal union but also as a process that can reveal systemic inequalities, particularly in financial and legal realms.

The request for alimony and legal expenses by Carrie Romney indicates concerns about financial security and access to justice, common themes in progressive discourse. It highlights the need for a system that ensures fair distribution of assets and provides support during transitions, reflecting values of equity and societal safety nets.

The deferred cause of death and the absence of criminal suspicion underscore the societal imperative to better understand and address the mental health and well-being of individuals experiencing personal crises. Progressives would argue for a compassionate approach that includes community support systems and comprehensive social services to aid those in distress.

Conservative View

The unfortunate demise of Carrie Elizabeth Romney, following George Scott Romney's divorce filing, underscores the complexities of marital dissolution and the importance of individual property rights. Traditionally, conservatives advocate for minimal court intervention in private matters, emphasizing the role of personal responsibility in financial affairs.

The agreement to mediate property and support aligns with conservative principles favoring private resolution over government involvement. It reflects an understanding that individuals are best equipped to determine their own interests, particularly in personal relationships. Moreover, George Scott Romney's decision to terminate the court's ability to award support could be seen as an assertion of self-reliance and a step away from dependency.

While the circumstances of Carrie Romney's death are tragic, the preceding divorce filings and the couple's financial negotiations are a reminder that marriage, in the conservative view, is not only a covenant but also a legal contract that should respect the autonomy of the individuals involved. The preference for mediation over court settlements is a testament to the conservative belief in the efficiency and fairness of private agreements.

Common Ground

In the midst of this personal tragedy involving George Scott Romney and the late Carrie Elizabeth Romney, common ground can be found in the shared belief that the legal system should fairly and effectively handle the dissolution of marriages. Both conservatives and progressives can agree on the need for a process that respects individual autonomy while ensuring justice and support for all parties involved.

There is also a mutual understanding of the importance of mental health resources and community support for individuals going through significant life changes, such as divorce. Acknowledging the emotional toll of such events, there is a bipartisan call for more accessible mental health services and public awareness about the impact of personal crises.

Ultimately, while the perspectives on how to achieve these goals may differ, the underlying values of fairness, respect for personal dignity, and community well-being resonate across the political spectrum.